On Moving On, and What Remains
Plus, our weekly crossword, extended interview, and more
In Sunday’s essay, we explored how Sunday in the Park with George and The Last Five Years are both organized around a central tension: the work that lasts, and the love that cannot quite be lived inside it. Today, we stay with that idea a little longer, turning to Sunday’s extraordinary second act, and to the conversation The Last Five Years never allows itself.
If you’re currently a free subscriber, consider upgrading to a premium subscription for full access to The Sondheim Hub: an exclusive essay, extended interview, crossword & more each week — plus, our complete, paywall-free library of 250+ essays, features & interviews.
“Move On” is, among other things, a miracle of dramatic construction. It takes place a century after Sunday’s first act, between a man paralyzed by creative exhaustion and a woman who has been dead for a hundred years. It is the conversation George and Dot never had, the one that couldn’t happen in their lifetimes, now made available across time through the strange alchemy of art and inheritance.
What Dot gives the younger George in “Move On” is not quite comfort, not quite absolution. It is that more practical, more radical thing: permission. Permission to stop worrying about whether the work is sufficient, whether the vision is new, whether the choices were mistaken. This is the show’s great act of generosity — the acknowledgment that the cost was real, the damage was real, but that none of it means the making, or the choosing, was wrong. Newness, it turns out, is the byproduct of sincerity. The problem George has been trying to solve dissolves the moment he stops trying to solve it.